Sunday, October 13, 2019

El Camino: A Breaking Bad Movie

**SPOILERS HEREIN**



Breaking Bad was one of the of the most beloved and acclaimed continuing television dramas ever made, and a rare one that pulled off an ending almost everyone liked. In fact, it sort of gave us two endings: the blaze of glory in the series finale, and the utter tragedy of “Ozymandias” two episodes prior (which I and others contend would have also worked as an ending). Both were satisfying in different ways.

But while the show brought the story of Walter White (Bryan Cranston) to a thorough conclusion, it didn’t quite find time to do the same for Jesse Pinkman (Aaron Paul). Walt’s former student and partner in crime—if never quite an onscreen equal to his old teacher, then at least the second most important and compelling character—became scarcer in the final season, and then drove off with little closure to his arc. Thus, we have El Camino, a coda that I’m sure will colloquially be called a bonus episode by many a viewer, but more accurately feels like a direct sequel. In any case, it’s a worthy successor and denouement to one of the most masterful shows to ever air.

The movie picks up immediately after Jesse’s final scream cut off in the finale (before the cops arrive after Walt’s massacre of the neo-Nazi gang, even), and extends it into a cry of anguish, not one of victory like the last episode made it seem. The fairly triumphant tone of the series’ final scene is absent and stays absent throughout, or at least muzzled. I’m not sure how long creator and director Vince Gilligan had these ideas in mind, but it seems appropriate that this final chapter comes a length of time after Braking Bad finished. Big, explosive sequences that leave an impression on viewers are more appropriate for final episodes. El Camino is about the aftermath of those big moments, and where the survivors go from there. It’s a similar vibe to the scenes of Walt’s exile in the show’s penultimate episode “Granite State.”

The story follows Jesse, his partner definitively dead and himself a fugitive, as he seeks out some money stashed away by one of his now-deceased captors so he can buy himself a new identity from Saul Goodman’s vacuum guy (Robert Forster). It’s a story that could have been told in a normal-length episode, with enough time left over for a subplot or two about the White family (none of whom appear, save for a cameo from Walt). But it’s a masterfully slow burn, building the type of seething tension one instantly recognizes from the show’s best moments. It plays like a sleek, somewhat self-contained little noir film, and Scott MacArthur is an appropriately mean foil. Not a Gus Fring or a Salamanca, not quite a forgettable one-and-done bad guy-of-the-week, just a real simple and nasty low-level criminal.

It also pads the length out to two hours with some overdue moments of mood and character. Jesse as a character never took to the coldblooded parts of the drug trade like Walt did, and the depictions of his damaged psyche (especially the season 4 scenes of him haunted by his first murder) were forceful and unsubtle, and so effective for it. El Camino tackles the trauma from his captivity at the hands of the Nazis (which Breaking Bad had little time to grapple with) much the same way, through pained silences that say so much, and flashbacks and apparitions that are haunting and intense.

It’s here where we get much of the character cameos, and surprisingly, it’s not all a load of fan service. Well, Walt’s kind of is (despite some dialogue that’s relevant to the proceedings, it feels like the most tacked-on of the bunch), but otherwise, they’re all worked in organically and fit the narrative. None more effectively than Todd’s (Jesse Plemons), whose horrific sequence plays like a black comedy with all the comedy drained out. Even for this series and this era of mature content, that might’ve been too much to show on basic cable.

It’s Aaron Paul’s show, however, and he’s so arresting he could have carried the movie even without any flashbacks bolstering or underlining his character’s mindset. Cranston was often so phenomenal as Walt that one could forget that Paul was also pretty excellent on the show as Jesse. With Heisenberg’s shadow absent in all but one scene, that doesn’t happen here (and that one scene comes late, after Paul’s been shining bright like a journeyman actor who knows this is a star-making role). Paul expertly conveys a man broken by one injury or devastation after another, but also sort of built up and made stronger by them.

But, not necessarily on the same path to ruin as Walter White. The climax of El Camino lets Jesse play action hero (or in this case, gunslinger) like his partner in “Felina,” but much more understatedly. Subsequently, he gets an ending somewhere between the two Walter got, melancholy but open-ended and contemplative. Jesse certainly broke bad and did some terrible things, but he was never fully consumed by the abyss like Walt. Maybe he has still a hope that his ex-teacher lost somewhere along the way (or perhaps never had in the first place). And that ending is, in its own way, very satisfying.

Monday, October 7, 2019

Joker

Well, you have to give Todd Phillips credit for something. Not for taking the superhero movie in a new direction, mind you (at least not any good one). Aside from a few shared names, Joker’s connections to its source material are so few that it feels like it's embarrassed of its DC Comics origins, a notion the writer-director-producer has done little to contradict in his public statements about the picture.

What Phillips has given us is the genre’s first unabashed piece of Oscar bait, aiming to beat Marvel to being the first Best Picture-winner after Black Panther broke the dam by being nominated just this year. Thus, Joker not only removes all the fun and fantastical “comic” elements to make it respectable enough for the Academy, but it’s also a showcase for a performance by an actor (that’d be Joaquin Phoenix) who’s long been acclaimed but so far hasn’t won an Academy Award (in other words, is “due”). But to that end, Phillips has concocted a uniquely awful type of awards-panderer where the pretentiousness crosses the line into hubris, matched by an incompetence that turns it from middling to rancid.

Instead of hitting the tropes Oscar voters like, the film opts to win praise by just copying movies critics already liked. The early 80s crime-ridden Gotham City merely evokes the hellish New York of Taxi Driver, but whole scenes are lifted from The King of Comedy (then taken to the obvious and bloody extreme for those who couldn’t grasp the effective subtlety of Martin Scorsese’s film). The aerial shots of Gotham cityscapes set to Hildur Guðnadóttir’s (good) score recall the urban realism and Hans Zimmer compositions of Christopher Nolan’s far superior Dark Knight trilogy. And as Phoenix's disaffected Arthur Fleck descends from party clown and wannabe standup comic into homicidal maniac, the narrative leaves no mentally ill villain trope unturned, and the ones meant to be twists or shocking are obvious from the outset.

Phoenix, to his credit, acts. In one of the very few original touches that works, this Joker is given an affectation that causes uncontrollable laughter regardless of the situation. In scenes where this plays a part, he’s so believable it’s painful. But like nearly every other idea, original or ripped-off, this only comes up sporadically at convenient points in the plot. In-between, Phoenix is merely elevating every movie bad guy stereotype of mental illness, from hallucinatory schizophrenics (or at least the misunderstood conditions movies file under “schizophrenia”) to internal-monologuing lone wolves. Despite only having a problematic Hollywood understanding of mental illness, the tone suggests the filmmakers truly believe they're providing a genuine and accurate portrait of it (albeit, tucked inside a supervillain origin story, however distanced from its comic book roots it may be). It’s totally uninformed, often insensitive, and when it's not unpleasant, it's just tedious. 

Joker is a movie that takes itself so seriously but doesn’t know what it’s talking about. Its attempts to say something about the times we live in—the film features a mass protest movement like Occupy with clown masks instead of Guy Fawkes, and a Thomas Wayne (Brett Cullen) who’s vaguely Trump-like—are a mishmash of right and left that not so much seeks some milquetoast middle ground as betrays a lack of understanding of current events (a problem shared by War Dogs, Phillips’ last semiserious attempt to go topical). It mistakes surface level mention of issues and ideas as depth, ugliness as realism, and misery as compelling drama. And the final nail in the coffin: the attempts at dark comedy land with a thud.